Smut Marathon 2020: First round results

Incredible. The first round of the third edition of the Smut Marathon is done. It’s time to present you with the results, but not before I have addressed the authors, the same as I did in the past two years.

Let’s talk about feedback… by now you have seen the feedback on your entries, but please, don’t let the feedback upset you. Read it — or not — and take from it what you can, or don’t. You are not obligated to take the feedback to heart, but if you do, use it to improve your writing in the next round. Implement it. Keep in mind that people who left feedback did it with their own frame of reference, and the reason why they did it, is to help you in some or other way. It’s not an attack on your writing, and if the feedback is negative, it doesn’t mean that you are a bad writer. Just take a deep breath, read the new assignment and start writing.

Also, when you see the points below, don’t despair, because so much can change in the second round. And… you are all through to that second round!

Let’s get on with the results of this round!

Authors

1. Lickety Clit – Tabitha Rayne
2. Silk Sheets – J.V. Speyer
3. Utter – Lenore DeLight
4. Longing – Floss Liddell
5. Gently greased – MeanMrWolf
6. Slow Sex – Édi Duarte
7. Anticipation – Dirty Romantic
8. Rhetorical Release – Beatrix_B
9. Brutal Blessings – Liz BlackX
10. Silk Scarf – S G Bound
11. Reunion – Peter Apps
12. Bad Boy – Eliza David
13. Suspended Animation – Marsha Adams
14. First Date – Amy Norton
15. Summer Seduction – Stephanie Scissom
16. Sweet Surrender – Jade Melisande
17. Three lovers – Natalie Kalian
18. Tied Taut – Lizzie
19. Luscious Landing – DeviantSuccubus
20. Sensual Seduction – Bella Cooper
21. Teenage Kicks – Hislordship
22. Besties – Tantivy Pierce
23. Waiting, Wanting – The Dark Escape
24. Seeking Sex – GaynorBlue
25. Carnal Consummation – Kisungura
26. Suspicious – Rose Shavelle
27. Slippery Sliders – Sweeten Dirty
28. It wakes – Zebra Rose
29. Quentin’s Competence – Lord Byron’s Ghost
30. Fisted – Friedrich Kreuz
31. One Look – JK Cummings
32. Tasting Menu – Frank Noir
33. Teetering Tension – mastersmusings
34. Fantasies – Stella Kiink
35. Her Hands – slave gefjon
36. Discreet Dancing – Johnny Jackhammer
37. Nightly Worship – J. Lynn
38. 20 lashes – Luv Bunny
39. Naughty Needs – Kurvy Kinkster
40. Moonshine Sculpting – Morris
41. Electric – Eva Leone
42. Callie – Septimus Writes
43. The Spanking – Chloe Sheila
44. Silken Sensation – Charlton C. Tod
45. Practicalities – loulou
46. Steamy Seduction – KC Clarke
47. Gal Pals – Don Juan Chernobyl
48. Blessed, be – Park View Princess
49. Waiting Approval – Chrisy Kay
50. Capriciously Chaotic – Raven Lee
51. Sensuous Salvation – Liza Daen
52. Mysterious Meeting – Lauren Crabtree
53. Prelude – Vee Lima
54. On Top – Annabel Lee
55. Pleasured pain – Escort Link UK
56. Lip Service – Bella Spelunked
57. Seeing Stars – Sienna Walker
58. Thirst – Sensualiser
59. Reciprocity – Cal
60. Spunky Spree – Carolyna Luna
61. Filthy Findings – Misty Dawn
62. Reversing roles – LoveLustLondon
63. Juicy Fruit – Lizzie Wasp
64. Bound Anticipation – Aoife Pheaca
65. Pink Sheets – Hyacinth Jones
66. Acute Adultery – Patricia Ray
67. First Felatio – Jade Greene
68. Girl Exposed – Ivy Augustine
69. The Release – Madame Gingembre
70. Tongue Twister – Taz Anderson
71. Anticlimax – S.T. Hills
72. Bejeweled – Jordan Monroe
73. Fierce Foreplay – Abby Williams
74. The F-word – Molly Jack
75. Surface scratches – Drew Stone
76. The Tease – Dawn Shelley
77. Undress – Helen Scott
78. The Whip – Dioscurus
79. First Time – Jennie Talia
80. Humidity – Mr Ruby
81. Come Together – Kinky Fielding
82. Midnight Mass – toolie
83. Stamina – Mahotsukai
84. Cuckold – My Naughty Ideas
85. Kneel – Ian Diamond
86. Silky Sensation – Nancy
87. New Religion – Aisling Weaver
88. Aural Sex – Tits McFadden
89. Written Lover – Darius Dunotte
90. The Trigger – Wayne Hills
91. Drenched – Mel
92. Summer Sin – OwenLars66
93. Frustrated Feelings – E.L. Byrne
94. Lucky – Zapatica
95. Best Behaviour – Perpetua Motion
96. Priscilla’s Passion – Ten Ways
97. The Pet – Calliope
98. Forbidden – Tortured Cyclone
99. Slipping inside – MLSlavePuppet
100. Split second – Vinyl Koala
101. Beginnings – Roan Marshall
102. Sultry Confinement – Jenby
103. The Ice – Hikari
104. Heaven – Shinygeekgirl
105. Lunch Break – Kristine Lynn
106. The Blindfold – lychee
107. Tender Touch – David
108. Kimono – Jacques
109. Enchantment – P. H. Xie

Public vote

During the voting round I keep track of all the votes, and when I see irregularities or strange patterns, I take action. The action can either be a warning to a writer, the elimination of a vote or the disqualification of a writer. I do give everyone the benefit of the doubt, but will not tolerate any cheating. Please note that the rules clearly say: one vote per person.

That said, let’s get down to the result of the public vote.

In total 132 legitimate votes have been received. Some people voted 3 times, others 4 and others 5 times. In total 578 selections have been made. The result of the voting can be found below.

Winner of the public vote: Tender Touch by David
First runner up: Anticipation by Dirty Romantic
Second runner up: Moonshine Sculpting by Morris

This is the full result of the public vote:

Author Story title Public votes Result
David Tender Touch 21 10
Dirty Romantic Anticipation 17 9
Morris Moonshine Sculpting 15 8
Roan Marshall Beginnings 14 7
Friedrich Kreuz Fisted 14 7
Jenby Sultry Confinement 13 6
Stella Kiink Fantasies 13 6
Escort Link UK Pleasured pain 13 6
Floss Liddell Longing 12 5
Ivy Augustine Girl Exposed 12 5
Tabitha Rayne Lickety Clit 12 5
Marsha Adams Suspended Animation 11 4
Liz BlackX Brutal Blessings 11 4
Cal Reciprocity 11 4
S.T. Hills Anticlimax 10 3
Jacques Kimono 10 3
GaynorBlue Seeking Sex 9 2
Taz Anderson Tongue Twister 9 2
OwenLars66 Summer Sin 9 2
S G Bound Silk Scarf 8 1
Tits McFadden Aural Sex 8 1
Natalie Kalian Three lovers 8 1
Chloe Sheila The Spanking 8 1
Carolyna Luna Spunky Spree 8 1
Calliope The Pet 7 1
Misty Dawn Filthy Findings 7 1
Jade Melisande Sweet Surrender 7 1
toolie Midnight Mass 7 1
Park View Princess Blessed, be 7 1
Lizzie Wasp Juicy Fruit 7 1
Rose Shavelle Suspicious 6 1
KC Clarke Steamy Seduction 6 1
Vinyl Koala Split second 6 1
My Naughty Ideas Cuckold 6 1
Perpetua Motion Best Behaviour 6 1
Helen Scott Undress 6 1
Zebra Rose It wakes 5 1
Dioscurus The Whip 5 1
Aoife Pheaca Bound Anticipation 5 1
Kristine Lynn Lunch Break 5 1
Ten Ways Priscilla’s Passion 5 1
Shinygeekgirl Heaven 5 1
Lord Byron’s Ghost Quentin’s Competence 5 1
Mahotsukai Stamina 5 1
Annabel Lee On Top 5 1
Aisling Weaver New Religion 5 1
Jade Greene First Felatio 4 1
Eliza David Bad Boy 4 1
Dawn Shelley The Tease 4 1
Jennie Talia First Time 4 1
Beatrix_B Rhetorical Release 4 1
DeviantSuccubus Luscious Landing 4 1
The Dark Escape Waiting, Wanting 4 1
Mr Ruby Humidity 4 1
lychee The Blindfold 4 1
Nancy Silky Sensation 4 1
Sweeten Dirty Slippery Sliders 4 1
Eva Leone Electric 4 1
Frank Noir Tasting Menu 4 1
Kurvy Kinkster Naughty Needs 4 1
Darius Dunotte Written Lover 4 1
Peter Apps Reunion 4 1
Amy Norton First Date 4 1
Drew Stone Surface scratches 3 1
J.V. Speyer Silk Sheets 3 1
Lauren Crabtree Mysterious Meeting 3 1
Bella Spelunked Lip Service 3 1
Sienna Walker Seeing Stars 3 1
Patricia Ray Acute Adultery 3 1
Hislordship Teenage Kicks 3 1
Lizzie Tied Taut 3 1
Kinky Fielding Come Together 3 1
Wayne Hills The Trigger 3 1
Lenore DeLight Utter 3 1
Liza Daen Sensuous Salvation 3 1
Édi Duarte Slow Sex 3 1
Septimus Writes Callie 3 1
Johnny Jackhammer Discreet Dancing 3 1
Luv Bunny 20 lashes 3 1
P. H. Xie Enchantment 3 1
Abby Williams Fierce Foreplay 3 1
Sensualiser Thirst 3 1
Chrisy Kay Waiting Approval 2 1
loulou Practicalities 2 1
Ian Diamond Kneel 2 1
J. Lynn Nightly Worship 2 1
Raven Lee Capriciously Chaotic 2 1
Tantivy Pierce Besties 2 1
E.L. Byrne Frustrated Feelings 2 1
Don Juan Chernobyl Gal Pals 2 1
MeanMrWolf Gently greased 2 1
Zapatica Lucky 2 1
Hikari The Ice 2 1
slave gefjon Her Hands 2 1
LoveLustLondon Reversing roles 2 1
Mel Drenched 2 1
Kisungura Carnal Consummation 2 1
Bella Cooper Sensual Seduction 1 1
Hyacinth Jones Pink Sheets 1 1
Tortured Cyclone Forbidden 1 1
mastersmusings Teetering Tension 1 1
Vee Lima Prelude 1 1
Madame Gingembre The Release 1 1
Jordan Monroe Bejeweled 0 0
MLSlavePuppet Slipping inside 0 0
JK Cummings One Look 0 0
Stephanie Scissom Summer Seduction 0 0
Charlton C. Tod Silken Sensation 0 0
Molly Jack The F-word 0 0

Jury vote

Each jury member sends in their votes individually. These votes are added up and divided by 5 to get to the jury results.

Winner of the jury vote: Fantasies by Stella Kiink
First runner up: Reunion by Peter Apps
Second runner up: Humidity by Mr Ruby

The jury’s votes are as follows:

Author Story title Jury 1 Jury 2 Jury 3 Jury 4 Jury 5 Jury result
Stella Kiink Fantasies 7 4 1 7 10 5,8
Peter Apps Reunion 1 7 1 9 9 5,4
Mr Ruby Humidity 10 1 8 6 1 5,2
Hislordship Teenage Kicks 1 1 10 8 1 4,2
Zebra Rose It wakes 1 8 1 1 8 3,8
Marsha Adams Suspended Animation 1 1 1 10 5 3,6
Tits McFadden Aural Sex 6 9 1 1 1 3,6
Aisling Weaver New Religion 1 1 9 1 6 3,6
Natalie Kalian Three lovers 1 10 1 1 1 2,8
Dioscurus The Whip 9 1 1 1 1 2,6
Jenby Sultry Confinement 8 1 1 1 1 2,4
Lauren Crabtree Mysterious Meeting 1 5 1 1 3 2,2
Beatrix_B Rhetorical Release 1 2 6 1 1 2,2
Vee Lima Prelude 1 1 1 1 7 2,2
Lizzie Wasp Juicy Fruit 1 1 7 1 1 2,2
GaynorBlue Seeking Sex 1 6 1 1 1 2,0
Sienna Walker Seeing Stars 1 1 1 5 1 1,8
DeviantSuccubus Luscious Landing 1 1 5 1 1 1,8
Stephanie Scissom Summer Seduction 5 1 1 1 1 1,8
Kristine Lynn Lunch Break 4 1 1 1 1 1,6
Eva Leone Electric 1 1 1 4 1 1,6
Ivy Augustine Girl Exposed 1 1 4 1 1 1,6
Kurvy Kinkster Naughty Needs 1 1 1 1 4 1,6
Helen Scott Undress 1 3 1 2 1 1,6
Floss Liddell Longing 1 1 1 3 1 1,4
Carolyna Luna Spunky Spree 3 1 1 1 1 1,4
Johnny Jackhammer Discreet Dancing 1 1 3 1 1 1,4
Bella Spelunked Lip Service 2 1 1 1 1 1,2
Friedrich Kreuz Fisted 1 1 1 1 2 1,2
MLSlavePuppet Slipping inside 1 1 2 1 1 1,2
Chrisy Kay Waiting Approval 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
S G Bound Silk Scarf 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
loulou Practicalities 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Drew Stone Surface scratches 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Ian Diamond Kneel 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Jade Greene First Felatio 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Bella Cooper Sensual Seduction 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
J.V. Speyer Silk Sheets 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Jordan Monroe Bejeweled 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Dirty Romantic Anticipation 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Roan Marshall Beginnings 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Eliza David Bad Boy 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Hyacinth Jones Pink Sheets 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Aoife Pheaca Bound Anticipation 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
J. Lynn Nightly Worship 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Morris Moonshine Sculpting 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Dawn Shelley The Tease 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
David Tender Touch 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Liz BlackX Brutal Blessings 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Cal Reciprocity 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Raven Lee Capriciously Chaotic 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Jennie Talia First Time 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Calliope The Pet 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
JK Cummings One Look 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
The Dark Escape Waiting, Wanting 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Patricia Ray Acute Adultery 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Chloe Sheila The Spanking 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Lizzie Tied Taut 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Tantivy Pierce Besties 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Rose Shavelle Suspicious 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Taz Anderson Tongue Twister 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
KC Clarke Steamy Seduction 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Misty Dawn Filthy Findings 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
lychee The Blindfold 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Charlton C. Tod Silken Sensation 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Kinky Fielding Come Together 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Tortured Cyclone Forbidden 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Wayne Hills The Trigger 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Nancy Silky Sensation 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Sweeten Dirty Slippery Sliders 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
mastersmusings Teetering Tension 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Vinyl Koala Split second 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
E.L. Byrne Frustrated Feelings 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Lenore DeLight Utter 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Liza Daen Sensuous Salvation 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Frank Noir Tasting Menu 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Ten Ways Priscilla’s Passion 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Darius Dunotte Written Lover 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Jade Melisande Sweet Surrender 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Édi Duarte Slow Sex 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Escort Link UK Pleasured pain 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Don Juan Chernobyl Gal Pals 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
My Naughty Ideas Cuckold 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Septimus Writes Callie 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
OwenLars66 Summer Sin 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Shinygeekgirl Heaven 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Lord Byron’s Ghost Quentin’s Competence 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
toolie Midnight Mass 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Perpetua Motion Best Behaviour 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
MeanMrWolf Gently greased 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Mahotsukai Stamina 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Molly Jack The F-word 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Luv Bunny 20 lashes 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Amy Norton First Date 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Zapatica Lucky 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Tabitha Rayne Lickety Clit 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Madame Gingembre The Release 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
P. H. Xie Enchantment 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Abby Williams Fierce Foreplay 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Annabel Lee On Top 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Hikari The Ice 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
S.T. Hills Anticlimax 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Park View Princess Blessed, be 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
slave gefjon Her Hands 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
LoveLustLondon Reversing roles 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Sensualiser Thirst 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Jacques Kimono 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Mel Drenched 1 1 1 1 1 1,0
Kisungura Carnal Consummation 1 1 1 1 1 1,0

Overall results

The public votes and that of the jury are added up to get to the end result for the round. For this round, this is also the result of the rankings, but for the next round that will change as writers accumulate results from the first to the sixth rounds.

The overall winner of round 1 is Stella Kiink with Fantasies

The overall result for round 1 and the rankings after round 1 are as follows:

Ranking Author Jury result Public result Overall result
1 Stella Kiink 5,8 6 11,8
2 David 1,0 10 11,0
3 Dirty Romantic 1,0 9 10,0
4 Morris 1,0 8 9,0
5 Jenby 2,4 6 8,4
6 Friedrich Kreuz 1,2 7 8,2
7 Roan Marshall 1,0 7 8,0
8 Marsha Adams 3,6 4 7,6
9 Escort Link UK 1,0 6 7,0
10 Ivy Augustine 1,6 5 6,6
11 Floss Liddell 1,4 5 6,4
Peter Apps 5,4 1 6,4
12 Mr Ruby 5,2 1 6,2
13 Tabitha Rayne 1,0 5 6,0
14 Hislordship 4,2 1 5,2
15 Liz BlackX 1,0 4 5,0
Cal 1,0 4 5,0
16 Zebra Rose 3,8 1 4,8
17 Tits McFadden 3,6 1 4,6
Aisling Weaver 3,6 1 4,6
18 GaynorBlue 2,0 2 4,0
S.T. Hills 1,0 3 4,0
Jacques 1,0 3 4,0
19 Natalie Kalian 2,8 1 3,8
20 Dioscurus 2,6 1 3,6
21 Lauren Crabtree 2,2 1 3,2
Beatrix_B 2,2 1 3,2
Vee Lima 2,2 1 3,2
Lizzie Wasp 2,2 1 3,2
22 Taz Anderson 1,0 2 3,0
OwenLars66 1,0 2 3,0
23 Sienna Walker 1,8 1 2,8
DeviantSuccubus 1,8 1 2,8
24 Kristine Lynn 1,6 1 2,6
Eva Leone 1,6 1 2,6
Kurvy Kinkster 1,6 1 2,6
Helen Scott 1,6 1 2,6
25 Carolyna Luna 1,4 1 2,4
Johnny Jackhammer 1,4 1 2,4
26 Bella Spelunked 1,2 1 2,2
27 Chrisy Kay 1,0 1 2,0
S G Bound 1,0 1 2,0
loulou 1,0 1 2,0
Drew Stone 1,0 1 2,0
Ian Diamond 1,0 1 2,0
Jade Greene 1,0 1 2,0
Bella Cooper 1,0 1 2,0
J.V. Speyer 1,0 1 2,0
Eliza David 1,0 1 2,0
Hyacinth Jones 1,0 1 2,0
Aoife Pheaca 1,0 1 2,0
J. Lynn 1,0 1 2,0
Dawn Shelley 1,0 1 2,0
Raven Lee 1,0 1 2,0
Jennie Talia 1,0 1 2,0
Calliope 1,0 1 2,0
The Dark Escape 1,0 1 2,0
Patricia Ray 1,0 1 2,0
Chloe Sheila 1,0 1 2,0
Lizzie 1,0 1 2,0
Tantivy Pierce 1,0 1 2,0
Rose Shavelle 1,0 1 2,0
KC Clarke 1,0 1 2,0
Misty Dawn 1,0 1 2,0
lychee 1,0 1 2,0
Kinky Fielding 1,0 1 2,0
Tortured Cyclone 1,0 1 2,0
Wayne Hills 1,0 1 2,0
Nancy 1,0 1 2,0
Sweeten Dirty 1,0 1 2,0
mastersmusings 1,0 1 2,0
Vinyl Koala 1,0 1 2,0
E.L. Byrne 1,0 1 2,0
Lenore DeLight 1,0 1 2,0
Liza Daen 1,0 1 2,0
Frank Noir 1,0 1 2,0
Ten Ways 1,0 1 2,0
Darius Dunotte 1,0 1 2,0
Jade Melisande 1,0 1 2,0
Édi Duarte 1,0 1 2,0
Don Juan Chernobyl 1,0 1 2,0
My Naughty Ideas 1,0 1 2,0
Septimus Writes 1,0 1 2,0
Shinygeekgirl 1,0 1 2,0
Lord Byron’s Ghost 1,0 1 2,0
toolie 1,0 1 2,0
Perpetua Motion 1,0 1 2,0
MeanMrWolf 1,0 1 2,0
Mahotsukai 1,0 1 2,0
Luv Bunny 1,0 1 2,0
Amy Norton 1,0 1 2,0
Zapatica 1,0 1 2,0
Madame Gingembre 1,0 1 2,0
P. H. Xie 1,0 1 2,0
Abby Williams 1,0 1 2,0
Annabel Lee 1,0 1 2,0
Hikari 1,0 1 2,0
Park View Princess 1,0 1 2,0
slave gefjon 1,0 1 2,0
LoveLustLondon 1,0 1 2,0
Sensualiser 1,0 1 2,0
Mel 1,0 1 2,0
Kisungura 1,0 1 2,0
28 Stephanie Scissom 1,8 0 1,8
29 MLSlavePuppet 1,2 0 1,2
30 Jordan Monroe 1,0 0 1,0
JK Cummings 1,0 0 1,0
Charlton C. Tod 1,0 0 1,0
Molly Jack 1,0 0 1,0

Next round

Thank you to everyone who has written for this round and thank you to all the voters who have taken the time to read the entries, to vote and for those who have given feedback. A special thanks to the jury members for their hard work!

No writers have to leave the marathon after this round, but at the end of the second round writers with the lowest overall points will be knocked out of the race, as we start round 3 with only 75 writers.

The writers will be sent the second assignment later today and have until midnight CET (Amsterdam time) on 26 February 2020 to send it in.

The next voting round opens on 1 March 2020, so readers, please make a note n your planners and don’t forget to come read and vote!

~ Marie Rebelle

4 Replies to “Smut Marathon 2020: First round results

    1. Thanks, May! Glad you liked “Lunch Break” 🙂 Loved the feedback on others’ stories as well. Lots to learn from on my end from reading them.

Comments are closed.